Washington legislator’s mind-boggling response to bicycle tax proposal

Facebook Twitter More...

When I read about a Washington legislator’s response to the proposed tax on bicycle sales, I honestly thought it was someone’s elementary attempt at sarcasm.

Rep. Ed Orcutt

Rep. Ed Orcutt

Wrong again.

State Rep. Ed Orcutt,  a Republican representing Kalama down in Cowlitz County, says bicycle riding is not an environmentally friendly activity. He wrote to a constituent:

“If I am not mistaken, a cyclist has an increased heart rate and respiration. That means that the act of riding a bike results in greater emissions of carbon dioxide from the rider. Since CO2 is deemed to be a greenhouse gas and a pollutant, bicyclists are actually polluting when they ride.”

OK. It’s nice to see a Republican actually use “science” in an argument, although I’d like to see the scientific study that concludes bicyclists add to global warming. [I wonder what he has planned for the bean industry.]

Orcutt says he’s generally not in favor of tax proposals, but he says that there are valid reasons to tax bicycles.

The issue came up after House Democrats proposed a huge transportation package that included $9.8 billion in new revenue over the next decade to pay for it. One provision called for a $25 tax on the sale of any bicycle costing more than $500, an action that would raise $1 million over the next 10 years.

House Transportation Chairman Rep. Judy Clibborn of Mercer Island, who submitted the transportation plan, says she doesn’t really approve of the $25 but submitted it as a symbolic gesture to Republicans who like to say bicyclists don’t pay their fair share.

Orcutt was responding to a letter from Dale Carlson, owner of Bike Tech in Tacoma, who was asking him to oppose the tax. Orcutt responded with the old argument that bicyclists don’t pay their fair share for roads and bike lanes, because they don’t pay a gasoline tax.

“I know, you own a car and drive so you are paying a gas tax — but not while you are riding your bike. When you are driving your car and generating gas tax you are also driving on the roads so are only really paying for the roads while driving — not biking.”

Apparently Orcutt, a member of the Transportation Committee, never looked at the facts on how roads are funded.

A study of figures in Seattle shows that the gasoline tax accounts for less than 1% of the local transportation department’s budget. Meanwhile, an analysis by the League of American Bicyclists  points out that motorists don’t pay for roads either — most of the cost is paid by property taxes, sales taxes, and bond issues.

There’s more coverage on this at SeattleBikeBlog, Cascade Bicycle Club blog, KentsBike Blog, and, appropriately, Comedy Central.



Permanent link to this article: https://www.bikingbis.com/2013/03/04/washington-legislators-mind-boggling-response-to-bicycle-tax-proposal/


Skip to comment form

    • Rushe on March 4, 2013 at 2:13 pm
    • Reply

    I sincerely hope all the voters who helped elect Mr. Orcutt have not suffered concussions from hitting themselves on the forehead as a result of his enlightened statements…

    • eric ritter on March 5, 2013 at 2:22 am
    • Reply

    that man is a F*ing IDIOT!!!! how on earth did he get elected to anything, ever??

    • Rick Akin on March 5, 2013 at 1:37 pm
    • Reply

    With that sort of thinking Ed Orcutt could have a great political future in Missouri

    1. I would happily donate to that political campaign!

    • iamacamera on March 31, 2013 at 4:05 pm
    • Reply

    What is really astonishing, as I read through the replies, is that no-one perceived what I immediately thought. This individual is getting a good laugh at your expense. Clearly it is meant as political satire. Quite effective judging by the responses here. Funny.

    • Durishin on May 15, 2015 at 7:02 am
    • Reply


    You are too stupid to be a Republican and, certainly, you are not a Conservative (wherein “conserve” is the root word).

    Basic biology: our metabolism uses oxygen and produces CO2, which, in turn, plants use to produce O2.

    Basic physics: a bicycle is simply the most efficient machine ever devised to move mankind. Efficiency here means work performed per energy used.

    You must be a product of public schools.

    • Marilyn Stern on May 19, 2015 at 8:40 am
    • Reply

    Has anyone checked out who funded his election campaign? How much came from Oil & Gas Industry I wonder? Republicans aren’t stupid. They are BOUGHT. (So are Democrats for that matter.)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.